Package bundled as esm only - no umd files

[WavyWalk]

Hello, your bundled package is esm and there is no umd artifacts.

This does not work by default with nextjs or jest.

This leads to some hacks like necessity to transpile your package, and complicates usage.

Could you please bundle with umd target as well like other esm first packages.

[merlinfuchs]

Hey @WavyWalk , thanks for bringing up this issue.

NextJS 13+ has native support for transpiling ESM modules, so it should work out of the box. If you are also experiencing this issue with Friendly Captcha v2 please report it there so we can fix it in the most recent version.

[WavyWalk]

@merlinfuchs , would be great to follow best practice here. We can make it work but this requires extra hacks, adding it to configurations, doing some unnecessary stuff in jest config. Bundling properly would be a quick win for you, and reduce pain in the ass for us.

[gzuidhof]

Hi @WavyWalk,

Would a CommonJS build perhaps be sufficient?

I'm a bit hesitant to add anything other than ESM, as the world is moving towards being ESM only (and I imagine we'll have to support whichever build format we add forever) - but if it's a real pain to support on your side, CJS seems to be preferable and the main format for anything legacy Node.

[WavyWalk]

@gzuidhof ,

CJS will be perfect as well.

I'm with you that it's moving to ESM, but the tools are behind.

In our case we have to do some extra steps and maintanance, which could be totally avoided.